6340 Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46220
(463) 207-0234austin@austincoon.com
School Guide 2026 · Central Indiana

The Best School Districts in Central Indiana

If you're moving to the Indianapolis area with kids, the school district drives the decision more than almost anything else. Here's an honest ranking of the suburban districts families ask me about most — what each does well, and what it costs to live there.

A classic central Indiana suburban high school campus

Last updated: September 26, 2026 | By Austin Coon, Indianapolis Realtor®

Carmel Clay Schools campus
1

Carmel Clay Schools

A+

Carmel

Carmel's flagship high school is one of the largest in the country and is consistently ranked among America's best, with elite academics, a nationally recognized performing arts program, and 30+ state championships in athletics. The district pairs that scale with unusually deep AP and International Baccalaureate offerings.

Carmel High School≈16,000 studentsAvg home: $680K
Nationally ranked Carmel HSTop-tier performing artsExtensive AP/IB optionsStrong special education programs
Zionsville Community Schools campus
2

Zionsville Community Schools

A+

Zionsville

Year in and year out, Zionsville posts some of the highest test scores and graduation rates in Indiana. The single high school keeps class sizes manageable, and the district's small-town, village feel makes it a favorite of families who want big-district results with a close-knit community.

Zionsville Community HS≈8,000 studentsAvg home: $748K
Highest ISTEP/ILEARN scores in the metroConsistent 4-year A ratingsAcademic-driven cultureVillage-style community
Hamilton Southeastern Schools campus
3

Hamilton Southeastern Schools

A

Fishers

Fishers is served by two outstanding high schools — Hamilton Southeastern and Fishers — meaning families get top-tier programming without a single-school bottleneck. The district is known for innovative programs, college/career readiness initiatives, and excellent extracurricular depth.

Fishers & HSE High Schools≈21,000 studentsAvg home: $500K
Two strong high schoolsInnovative CTE programsCollege & career readiness focusGrowing but well-managed
Westfield Washington Schools campus
4

Westfield Washington Schools

A

Westfield

Westfield is the fastest-growing district on this list, and the schools have kept pace. Westfield High School earns top marks in academics and athletics, and new construction across the city means many families get modern facilities and newer housing stock at a slight discount to Carmel.

Westfield High School≈9,000 studentsAvg home: $489K
Fastest-growing districtModern facilitiesStrong athleticsMore home for the money
Center Grove Community Schools campus
5

Center Grove Community Schools

A

Greenwood

Center Grove delivers Hamilton County-level schooling at Johnson County prices. The high school is a perennial powerhouse in academics and athletics, and it has been named one of Indiana's best high schools repeatedly. For value, it's hard to beat south of the city.

Center Grove HS≈9,000 studentsAvg home: $350K
Best value on the listState-championship athleticsA-rated for over a decadeLower property taxes
Brownsburg Community Schools campus
6

Brownsburg Community Schools

A

Brownsburg

Brownsburg pairs an A-rated district with a hometown identity on the west side. The high school is known statewide for its engineering and robotics programs, and the district's steady academic performance draws families who want strong schools with an established, small-city feel.

Brownsburg HS≈9,000 studentsAvg home: $376K
Nationally ranked roboticsEngineering & STEM focusEstablished communityAccess to I-74 corridor
Noblesville Schools campus
7

Noblesville Schools

A

Noblesville

Noblesville has invested heavily in modern facilities, including a redesigned high school built around flexible learning and innovation programming. Add a charming historic square and Morse Reservoir, and it's a well-rounded package for families watching their budget more closely.

Noblesville HS≈10,000 studentsAvg home: $428K
Innovation & flexible learningNewer high school facilityHistoric downtown squareMorse Reservoir lifestyle
Avon Community Schools campus
8

Avon Community Schools

A

Avon

Avon rounds out the west side with a large, well-run district. The high school's marching band is a national-championship dynasty, athletics are competitive, and academics earn consistent A marks — all at one of the friendliest price points for top-tier schools in the metro.

Avon HS≈9,000 studentsAvg home: $335K
National-champion marching bandCompetitive athleticsConsistent A ratingsWest-side value
Also Worth a Look

Honorable Mentions

Plainfield Community Schools

Fast-improving west-side district with new facilities and strong community support.

Franklin Township Schools

Solid east-side option with good ratings and more affordable housing.

Perry Township Schools

One of the strongest township districts inside Marion County, with a dual-language immersion program.

How I Ranked Them

How These Rankings Were Determined

This isn't just a test-score list. As a realtor, I see which districts actually deliver for families — and what they cost. The ranking weighs:

  • Academic results: state accountability grades, ILEARN and SAT performance, graduation rates
  • Program depth: AP/IB offerings, STEM, arts, and extracurricular strength
  • Facilities and growth: modern buildings and how well the district manages expansion
  • Value: what it actually costs to buy into the district

Ratings are approximate and change year to year — always verify current boundaries and scores with the district and the Indiana Department of Education before buying.

Moving for Schools? Start With the Right District

I help families buy into the right central Indiana school district every week — including boundary checks before you write an offer. Tell me your kids' ages and your budget, and I'll point you to the right neighborhoods.

Take the Dream Home QuizCall Austin: (463) 207-0234